everydrop Filter 1 vs GE XWFE: Which Refrigerator Filter Is Better in 2026?

Quick Verdict: The GE XWFE ($25–$50) edges ahead on specs with 300-gallon capacity and 50+ contaminant reduction. The everydrop Filter 1 ($50–$100) delivers excellent 99% lead reduction and triple NSF certification but at lower capacity (200 gal). Your fridge brand determines your choice — GE fridges need the XWFE, Whirlpool-family fridges need the everydrop.

everydrop by Whirlpool Refrigerator Filter 1 (EDR1RXD1)

GE XWFE Refrigerator Water Filter

At a Glance

Feature	everydrop by Whirlpool Refrigerator Filter 1 (EDR1RXD1)	Editor's Pick GE XWFE Refrigerator Water Filter
Price	$50–$100	$25–$50
Capacity	200 gallons	300 gallons
Certifications	NSF 42/53/401	NSF 42/53/401
Filter Life	6 months or 200 gallons	6 months or 300 gallons
Compatibility	Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, KitchenAid, JennAir (Filter 1 models)	GE refrigerators (XWFE compatible models)
Filtration	Activated Carbon Block	Activated Carbon Block
	Check Price	Check Price

The everydrop Filter 1 and GE XWFE are the top OEM refrigerator filters from the two largest American appliance makers. Both carry triple NSF certification and deliver premium filtration. This comparison helps you understand which offers more — even though your fridge brand ultimately makes the decision for you.

Category-by-Category Breakdown

Contaminant Removal

The GE XWFE claims removal of 50+ contaminants, including PFOA, PFOS, microplastics, lead, and cysts. The everydrop Filter 1 reduces 99% of lead, plus pharmaceuticals, pesticides, and waterborne parasites. Both carry NSF 42/53/401 — the premium triple certification covering chlorine taste, health contaminants, and emerging pollutants. The XWFE's explicit 50+ contaminant count and microplastics reduction give it a slight edge in breadth, but the everydrop's 99% lead reduction rate is the highest in our test group. The microplastics certification on the XWFE is particularly relevant for households concerned about emerging contaminant research — microplastic particles have been detected in most U.S. municipal water supplies according to recent studies.

Winner: Tie — XWFE for breadth, everydrop for lead

Capacity & Filter Life

The XWFE provides 300 gallons per filter versus 200 gallons for the everydrop. Both are rated for 6-month replacement cycles, but the XWFE's 50% greater capacity means it maintains peak performance longer in heavy-use households. For a family using 2-3 gallons daily, the XWFE lasts well past the 6-month mark, while the everydrop hits its 200-gallon limit in roughly 3-4 months under the same conditions. Households that rely heavily on their ice maker should factor in that ice production alone can consume 3-4 gallons per day, which dramatically accelerates filter depletion on the lower-capacity everydrop.

Winner: GE XWFE (300 vs 200 gallons)

Price & Value

Both filters sit in the $50–$100 range, but the XWFE delivers 300 gallons compared to the everydrop's 200 — a 50% capacity advantage at a slightly lower sticker price. That translates to a dramatically lower cost per gallon for the XWFE, roughly 40% cheaper per gallon than the everydrop. The XWFE wins on both upfront price and long-term economics, making it the better value on every metric. The everydrop's slight premium reflects its OEM Whirlpool branding rather than superior filtration economics.

Winner: GE XWFE (~40% cheaper per gallon)

Ease of Installation

Both filters are designed for tool-free installation. The XWFE uses a twist-and-lock mechanism that takes about 30 seconds. The everydrop Filter 1 uses a push-in design that can be slightly tricky on first installation — some users report needing extra force to seat it properly. A common tip is to lightly wet the O-ring gaskets before insertion, which reduces friction and helps the everydrop slide into place more smoothly. For ongoing replacements, both are straightforward. The XWFE's twist-lock is marginally more intuitive for first-time users.

Winner: GE XWFE (easier twist-and-lock)

Brand Trust & Reviews

The everydrop Filter 1 has an impressive 32,000+ reviews with a 4.6-star rating — the highest-rated and most-reviewed filter in this comparison. The GE XWFE has 22,000+ reviews with a 4.5-star rating. Both have overwhelming positive feedback. The everydrop's larger review base and slightly higher rating suggest more consistent user satisfaction across a wider installed base. For Whirlpool-family fridge owners, the everydrop brand has strong trust.

Winner: everydrop Filter 1 (4.6 stars, 32K reviews)

Who Should Get Which?

Get the everydrop by Whirlpool Refrigerator Filter 1 (EDR1RXD1) if...

You own a Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, KitchenAid, or JennAir refrigerator
You want the highest-rated OEM filter with 32,000+ positive reviews
Lead reduction is your top priority (99% certified removal)

Check Price on Amazon

Get the GE XWFE Refrigerator Water Filter if...

You own a GE refrigerator compatible with XWFE filters
You want the highest capacity fridge filter available (300 gallons)
You want 50+ contaminant reduction including microplastics

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a GE XWFE filter in a Whirlpool refrigerator?

No. GE and Whirlpool/everydrop filters have completely different physical designs and connection mechanisms. The GE XWFE only fits GE refrigerators, and the everydrop Filter 1 only fits Whirlpool-family fridges (Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, KitchenAid, JennAir). You must use the filter designed for your specific refrigerator brand and model.

Which filter removes more contaminants — everydrop Filter 1 or GE XWFE?

The GE XWFE removes 50+ contaminants including PFOA, PFOS, and microplastics. The everydrop Filter 1 reduces 99% of lead plus pharmaceuticals, pesticides, and waterborne parasites. Both carry NSF 42/53/401 certification. The XWFE has been tested against a larger number of specific substances, but both provide excellent, comprehensive filtration.

Why does the GE XWFE have more capacity than the everydrop Filter 1?

The GE XWFE offers 300 gallons compared to 200 gallons for the everydrop. This likely comes down to the carbon block design and internal filter media volume. The XWFE's larger capacity means it lasts longer before needing replacement, making it cheaper per gallon despite a similar sticker price.

Do both of these filters use RFID technology?

The GE XWFE uses an RFID chip that the refrigerator must detect before allowing water/ice functions. The everydrop Filter 1 does not use RFID but is designed to fit only compatible Whirlpool-family refrigerators through its physical design. The RFID on GE filters prevents aftermarket alternatives, while everydrop filters can theoretically be substituted with compatible aftermarket options.

Which filter is cheaper in the long run?

The GE XWFE costs $49.49 for 300 gallons ($0.16/gallon), while the everydrop Filter 1 costs $53.99 for 200 gallons ($0.27/gallon). The XWFE is about 40% cheaper per gallon. However, you can only use the filter that fits your fridge — there is no cross-compatibility.